1 What is Business Intelligence?

PRELIMINARY AND INCOMPLETE

Business Intelligence (BI) is a comprehensive process through which organizations utilize data to address challenges and improve decision-making. A prime example of BI at work is Target’s deployment of SAP BusinessObjects. This tool enables Target to systematically analyze data from point-of-sale systems, inventory databases, and customer feedback. By extracting and interpreting purchasing patterns and seasonal trends, Target can optimize its inventory to align with regional customer demands. For instance, by identifying heightened demand for organic products in specific areas, Target adeptly adjusts its stock levels to minimize overstock of less popular items. This strategic use of BI not only boosts operational efficiency and customer satisfaction but also enhances Target’s ability to adapt and thrive in a competitive market, demonstrating how BI processes empower organizations to effectively use their data for tangible business improvements (J. Smith 2021).

1.1 Chapter Goals

Upon concluding this chapter, readers will be able to:

Understand the fundamental concepts and strategic importance of Business Intelligence (BI) in enhancing organizational decision-making and competitive advantage.
Recognize the practical applications and benefits of BI across various industries, including retail, healthcare, and more, and how it can optimize operations, improve customer insights, and drive growth.
Grasp key BI concepts and terminology such as data mining, data warehousing, OLAP, and dashboards, and understand their roles in the BI ecosystem.
Identify and evaluate the key tools and technologies used in BI, such as Microsoft Power BI, Tableau, SAP BusinessObjects, QlikView, R, and RStudio, and appreciate their unique contributions to data analysis and visualization.
Analyze real-world case studies, such as the implementation of BI in Starbucks, to understand how organizations successfully integrate BI into their strategic planning and operational processes.
Navigate the ethical considerations in BI, particularly concerning data privacy, security, and integrity, and understand the importance of ethical practices in data management and analysis.
Critically assess the implications of BI in specialized contexts, such as student monitoring systems in universities, and understand the balance between leveraging BI for benefits and maintaining ethical standards and privacy considerations.

1.2 Introduction

Business Intelligence (BI) refers to the comprehensive array of technologies, applications, strategies, and practices that are employed to collect, integrate, analyze, and present an organization’s information. The primary aim of BI is to support and improve the decision-making processes within a company. By using BI systems, businesses can efficiently gather, store, access, and analyze corporate data to make well-informed strategic decisions (Wixom and Watson 2010).

BI technologies provide historical, current, and predictive views of business operations. They often use data gathered in a data warehouse or a data mart and occasionally work from operational data. Applications in BI can cover a variety of areas including query and reporting, online analytical processing (OLAP), statistical analysis, forecasting, and data mining (H. Chen, Chiang, and Storey 2012).

The effectiveness of BI is in its ability to aid businesses in understanding the intricate patterns hidden within big data, thereby enabling them to identify market trends, detect business problems, and derive actionable insights. For instance, through the careful analysis of customer behavior and market conditions, companies can tailor their strategies to better meet consumer demands and stay competitive in the market (Shollo and Kautz 2010).

1.3 Practical Applications of BI

Business Intelligence (BI) finds its utility in a myriad of real-world scenarios, each tailored to enhance specific aspects of a business. In the retail sector, companies leverage BI to analyze sales data, identifying prevailing trends, forecasting future demand, and optimizing inventory management (Bose 2009). These insights allow retailers to not only align their stock with current consumer preferences but also predict future market conditions, thereby improving profitability and customer satisfaction.

Similarly, in the healthcare sector, BI tools are instrumental in elevating patient care standards. By enabling the thorough analysis of treatment outcomes, healthcare providers can identify effective treatments and areas needing improvement (Wang, Kung, and Byrd 2018). This data-driven approach helps in developing better healthcare practices and improving patient outcomes through more personalized and timely care.

Furthermore, BI is extensively used in the financial services industry. Financial institutions employ BI for risk management, customer segmentation, and fraud detection (H. Chen, Chiang, and Storey 2012). By analyzing historical transaction data, BI systems can identify patterns that indicate fraudulent activities, helping institutions prevent substantial financial losses and protect customer information.

Lastly, BI applications in the public sector include performance management and regulatory compliance. Government agencies utilize BI to monitor and improve their services, ensuring efficient resource use and enhanced service delivery to the public (Joseph2003?). Additionally, BI systems help in adhering to regulatory requirements by providing tools that ensure compliance through continuous monitoring and reporting.

Case Study: Starbucks

Starbucks, renowned for its emphasis on exceptional customer experiences and high-quality products, leverages advanced Business Intelligence (BI) tools to enhance customer service and operational efficiency. The company has adopted a range of BI technologies, including data analytics platforms, customer relationship management (CRM) systems, and location analytics tools. These tools are integral in driving business growth and customer satisfaction through personalized marketing and strategic decision-making.

Starbucks employs sophisticated data analytics platforms like Microsoft Power BI and Tableau to process and visualize large datasets from its loyalty programs, mobile app interactions, and in-store transactions. This enables them to identify purchasing trends, customer preferences, and peak operational times. Additionally, Starbucks utilizes CRM systems to manage and analyze customer interactions and data throughout the customer lifecycle, aiming to improve business relationships with customers, specifically focusing on customer retention and ultimately driving sales growth.

Furthermore, Starbucks harnesses location analytics tools such as Esri’s ArcGIS to determine the most strategic locations for new stores. This GIS technology allows them to analyze demographic data, traffic patterns, and proximity to other Starbucks locations to optimize their physical presence and enhance accessibility for customers.

Despite these technological advancements, Starbucks faces challenges in data privacy and the complexity of synchronizing data across diverse sources. This necessitates robust data management solutions to maintain data consistency and security, ensuring the reliability of business insights derived from BI tools. Through the effective use of these BI technologies, Starbucks not only improves its operational efficiencies but also sets a strong precedent in the retail sector for integrating data-driven strategies to enhance customer satisfaction and business performance.

1.4 Navigating the Business Intelligence Landscape: Key Concepts and Workflow

Business Intelligence (BI) involves a systematic approach to data management and analysis that supports strategic decision-making. A comprehensive understanding of the complete BI workflow is essential to harness its full potential effectively.

The BI process begins with Data Collection, where data is gathered from various sources including internal systems like ERP and CRM, and external sources such as market research reports and social media platforms. The aim is to collect a diverse spectrum of data that reflects all aspects of the business environment (Loshin 2013).

Following collection, the Data Integration stage involves consolidating this data into a cohesive format. This process includes resolving inconsistencies and standardizing information across datasets, often using data integration tools to fit data into a warehouse schema (Vassiliadis 2009).

Once integrated, data is stored in a Data Warehouse, a central repository that supports query and analysis, providing a stable and efficient platform for BI applications. This centralization is crucial as it allows the stored data to be a single source of truth for the organization (Inmon 2005).

The next phase, Data Analysis, involves two major activities: Formal Modeling and Data Mining. Formal modeling refers to creating abstract models that represent underlying business processes or systems through mathematical or simulation approaches. This type of modeling is essential for theoretical analysis and helps in developing hypotheses about business outcomes (Saltz and Dewar 2019). Data Mining, on the other hand, involves analyzing large datasets to discover patterns that predict future behavior and inform decision-making. This can be categorized into:

Descriptive Mining, which focuses on identifying and interpreting patterns that describe the data. This approach helps organizations understand their operational environment by elucidating how different data elements are interrelated. Descriptive mining techniques include clustering, which groups similar data items together to highlight natural segmentation; association rule mining, which identifies interesting correlations between variables; and sequence discovery, which predicts the occurrence of certain events based on identified patterns. These techniques enable businesses to gain insights into customer behaviors, operational inefficiencies, and market trends, thus providing a basis for tactical decisions aimed at enhancing operational effectiveness. For instance, retailers can use clustering to segment their customers based on purchasing patterns, allowing for targeted marketing strategies that are more likely to resonate with each segment (Berry and Linoff 2011).
Predictive Mining , which uses historical data to forecast future outcomes. This approach employs statistical techniques and machine learning algorithms to build models that can forecast future events based on past patterns. This form of mining provides a competitive edge by enabling companies to anticipate market trends and customer needs before they manifest explicitly (Han, Kamber, and Pei 2011).

Reporting and Visualization are essential in transforming analyzed data into understandable reports and visualizations. Tools such as dashboards and scorecards are used, helping stakeholders quickly interpret the information and make informed decisions (Few 2006).

The final phase, Performance Management, involves monitoring and managing performance based on insights derived from BI tools, setting benchmarks, and refining strategies based on data-driven insights (Dresner 2007).

1.5 The Value Proposition of BI

The utility of Business Intelligence (BI) extends far beyond the realm of simple data analysis, providing organizations with a transformative toolkit that revolutionizes how they operate and compete in the marketplace. BI systems empower companies by enabling better decision-making processes that are rooted in data-driven evidence. This transition to data-backed decisions enhances the quality and reliability of the outcomes, making strategic and operational decisions more precise and effective (Shollo and Kautz 2010).

Additionally, BI significantly contributes to increasing operational efficiency. By elucidating and analyzing operational costs and pinpointing inefficiencies, BI tools play a crucial role in identifying areas ripe for improvement. This capability allows organizations to streamline processes, reduce waste, and leverage their resources more effectively, leading to improved profitability and efficiency (Wixom and Watson 2010).

Furthermore, BI provides enhanced insights into customer behaviors and trends. Through the detailed analysis of customer data, businesses can gain a deeper understanding of their clients’ needs and preferences. This intelligence enables companies to tailor their products and services to better meet customer expectations and to create targeted marketing strategies that increase engagement and satisfaction (H. Chen, Chiang, and Storey 2012).

The competitive edge provided by BI is particularly valuable in today’s data-driven market landscape. With the ability to analyze vast amounts of data and glean actionable insights, companies equipped with robust BI capabilities can anticipate market trends, adapt to changes more swiftly, and differentiate themselves from competitors. This strategic advantage is critical in maintaining relevance and achieving sustained success in any industry (Popovic2012?).

In summary, BI stands as a cornerstone of modern business strategy, offering a comprehensive toolkit for enhancing decision-making, operational efficiency, customer understanding, and competitive positioning through astute data analysis. The multifaceted benefits of BI underscore its indispensable role in helping organizations navigate complex market dynamics and capitalize on growth opportunities.

1.6 Key Tools Used in Business Intelligence

In the dynamic field of Business Intelligence (BI), a variety of tools and platforms stand out for transforming raw data into actionable insights. Microsoft Power BI is one such tool, offering a comprehensive suite of business analytics tools designed to deliver insights throughout an organization, thereby facilitating a unified view of critical data points (Janssen 2019). Similarly, Tableau is celebrated for its powerful visual analytics engine, renowned for making the interpretation of complex datasets more accessible through interactive and visually compelling analytics (Chabrow2018?).

SAP BusinessObjects expands the BI toolkit by providing a centralized suite for reporting, visualization, and collaborative sharing of BI insights, which enhances decision-making processes across different levels of an organization (Davenport 2013). In a similar vein, QlikView offers interactive dashboards and analytics that turn complex data into understandable knowledge, enabling strategic business decisions (Barrett 2016).

Among these tools, R and RStudio are particularly pivotal in the realm of advanced analytics and data processing in BI. R is a programming language dedicated to statistical computing and graphics, highly regarded for its extensive applications in BI, especially in advanced analytics. It provides robust tools for data manipulation, statistical modeling, and intricate data visualization, enabling a deeper understanding of data patterns and trends (Muenchen 2017).

R’s integration into BI extends to the creation of customizable dashboards and reports, allowing for tailored insights that meet specific organizational needs. Moreover, R excels in predictive modeling, leveraging its statistical prowess to forecast future trends and behaviors, an essential capability for forward-looking business strategies. It is also adept at handling large datasets, a critical requirement for effective data mining and warehousing in BI, ensuring that businesses can efficiently process and analyze vast volumes of information.

This text adopts a coding approach to BI tools because coding provides an in-depth understanding of the processes “under the hood.” This knowledge demystifies the operations involved and equips professionals with skills that are transferable across different systems, including GUI and AI-based tools. An understanding of coding also liberates individuals from reliance on the analyses of others, fostering a deeper engagement with the data and the analytics process.

The table below provides an overview of the tools discussed in this section. This selection of software serves as illustrative examples within the broader BI landscape, which is rich with diverse tools and platforms. It’s important to note that the tools listed here represent just a fraction of the options available, and the capabilities of these tools evolve almost daily, reflecting rapid advancements in technology and user demands. The descriptions aim to outline how each tool fits into the BI ecosystem, highlighting their respective strengths and weaknesses to aid in understanding their potential impact on business operations.

BI Tool	Role in BI Ecosystem	Strengths	Weaknesses
Microsoft Power BI	Primarily used for creating dashboards and reports, integrating data from various sources.	User-friendly interface Strong integration with other Microsoft products Real-time access to data	Can be expensive for large teams Limited data handling capabilities compared to some competitors
Tableau	Focuses on data visualization and creating interactive, shareable dashboards.	Powerful visual analytics Intuitive drag-and-drop interface Capable of handling large datasets	Steeper learning curve Higher cost
SAP BusinessObjects	Provides a comprehensive suite for reporting, visualization, and sharing of BI insights.	Robust enterprise-level reporting Strong administrative controls Integrates well with SAP environments	Complex for new users Can be resource-intensive
QlikView	Used for guided analytics, interactive dashboards, and associative exploration of data.	Fast associative data indexing In-memory processing enhances speed Flexible and customizable	Steep learning curve for developers High licensing cost
R and RStudio	Employed for advanced analytics, statistical modeling, and intricate data visualization.	Powerful statistical analysis capabilities Open-source and flexible Extensive community support	Requires programming knowledge Less intuitive UI compared to dedicated BI tools

1.7 Ethical Considerations in Business Intelligence

The integration of Business Intelligence (BI) into organizational processes introduces a range of ethical considerations that are imperative for companies to address, ensuring the responsible handling of data and analytics. The ethical landscape of BI is particularly influenced by critical issues concerning the privacy and security of data, the accuracy and integrity of the information analyzed, and the potential for the misuse of such information.

Data Privacy and Security

At the forefront of ethical considerations is the protection of personal data, which mandates that customer information is collected, stored, and used in a manner that upholds and protects individual privacy rights. This involves implementing robust security measures aimed at thwarting unauthorized access or breaches of data. Ethical practices in this area include obtaining explicit consent from individuals prior to the collection of their data, anonymizing information to safeguard individual identities, and continuously revising and enhancing security protocols to counter new threats (Martin 2016). Special precautions are particularly critical when the data pertains to children, requiring organizations to navigate additional legal and ethical obligations to protect minors’ data effectively.

Data Accuracy and Integrity

Ensuring the accuracy and integrity of data is another pivotal aspect of BI ethics. Organizations must ensure that the data they gather and utilize for BI purposes is both reliable and devoid of bias, avoiding skewed data collection and analysis methods that could lead to misleading results. Ethical practices here encompass the establishment of verification processes to confirm data accuracy and a proactive approach to identifying and mitigating any potential biases within data sets (Kitchin 2014).

Misuse of Information

The risk of information misuse presents significant ethical challenges. The potential for data manipulation for unscrupulous purposes, such as deceiving stakeholders or rationalizing unethical business practices, necessitates the formulation of clear guidelines regarding the proper use of BI data. Maintaining transparency in the application and reporting of data helps prevent privacy violations that could emerge from the excessive surveillance of employees or customers through BI tools (Boyd and Crawford 2012).

Accountability and Governance

Accountability and governance are integral to the ethical deployment of BI. It is crucial to clarify who bears responsibility for decisions informed by BI insights and to ensure that BI practices comply with legal and regulatory standards. This involves assigning explicit responsibility for data-driven decisions and regularly auditing BI procedures to verify compliance, thus upholding ethical standards in BI practices (Tene and Polonetsky 2013).

Special Ethical Considerations Regarding Children

Protecting children’s data in the digital age requires special ethical and legal considerations, particularly as it pertains to their vulnerability and the potential for misuse of their information. The protection of children’s data is governed by specific regulations that vary by jurisdiction but share common principles of safeguarding minor’s privacy and limiting data collection.

YouTube’s operations in Australia illustrate the complexities involved in BI ethics, particularly concerning children’s data. The platform adjusted its data collection and processing practices to meet the stringent requirements of Australian data protection laws, which focus intensively on safeguarding children’s privacy. This example underscores the importance of BI systems being flexible and responsive to differing international laws and ethical norms, especially in a digital age where data flows across borders with ease (L. Chen et al. 2022).

Here is an overview of some key laws specifically aimed at protecting children’s data, along with their geographic jurisdiction and a brief discussion of compliance:

Law	Geographic Jurisdiction	Brief Discussion of Compliance
Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA)	United States	COPPA requires websites and online services to obtain parental consent before collecting personal information from children under the age of 13. It also mandates that operators post clear privacy policies and provide parents with the ability to review and delete their children’s information.
General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) - Articles Specific to Children	European Union	GDPR includes specific provisions to protect children’s personal data, particularly in the context of commercial internet services such as social networking. Consent for data processing must be given by the child’s legal guardian if the child is below the age of 16 (this age may vary slightly depending on the member state).
Protection of Children’s Personal Information Act	South Korea	This Act includes provisions to ensure that children’s personal information is collected and processed with parental consent and that data is adequately protected against unauthorized access and breaches.
Australian Privacy Principles (APP) - Child Protection	Australia	The Australian Privacy Principles outline stringent requirements for handling the personal information of children. These principles mandate obtaining parental consent for data collection from minors and include guidelines for the secure management and use of this data, emphasizing the importance of protecting children’s privacy in the digital realm.

Implications of International Data Protection Laws

The global landscape of data protection laws requires BI practices to adapt to a variety of legal frameworks, each with its own set of rules and penalties for non-compliance. For instance, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the European Union has set a precedent with its stringent data protection standards, which influence not only EU-based businesses but also those outside the EU that handle EU residents’ data. These laws necessitate that BI systems be designed to ensure data privacy, secure data management, and accountability at all stages of data handling.

Here is an overview of some key international data protection laws and their implications for BI practices:

Law	Geographic Jurisdiction	Brief Discussion of Compliance
General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)	European Union	GDPR imposes strict guidelines on data collection, processing, and storage, including the need for explicit consent, data minimization, and the right for individuals to have their data erased. Companies must also implement adequate security measures and report data breaches within a specific timeframe. Non-compliance can result in substantial fines.
California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)	California, United States	The CCPA provides California residents with the right to know about the personal data collected on them, including whether it is being sold and to whom. It also allows consumers to opt out of the sale of their personal data and request the deletion of their data. Businesses need to ensure transparent data handling practices and provide mechanisms for consumers to exercise their rights.
Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA)	Canada	PIPEDA requires businesses to obtain consent when collecting, using, or disclosing personal information in the course of commercial activity. Organizations must protect personal information with appropriate security measures and make their policies on data handling accessible to individuals. They must also provide avenues for complaint and redress regarding the handling of personal information.
Data Protection Act 2018	United Kingdom	This Act controls how personal information is used by organizations, businesses, or the government. It aligns with the GDPR and mandates similar compliance measures, such as data subject consent, data accuracy, and minimization, and mandates impact assessments for high-risk processing.
Lei Geral de Proteção de Dados (LGPD)	Brazil	LGPD shares similarities with GDPR and mandates data processing frameworks that protect the rights of data subjects, including consent, data access requests, and the right to deletion. Businesses are expected to appoint a data protection officer and report any data breaches in a timely manner.

Ethical considerations are foundational to the practice of BI, crucial for maintaining trust and integrity within business operations. It is essential to recognize that ethical handling of BI extends beyond mere legal compliance; it involves treating all stakeholders in the BI process with decency and integrity. By adopting responsible data management and analysis practices that emphasize privacy, accuracy, and ethical information use, organizations can leverage BI not only as a tool for strategic advantage but also as a platform for positive change, avoiding the pitfalls of ethical transgressions. This approach fosters a culture of trust and respect, enhancing relationships with customers, employees, and other stakeholders. Moreover, paying special attention to vulnerable populations, such as children, further enhances the ethical standing of BI practices, ensuring that these tools contribute positively to society. In this way, ethical BI practices become a cornerstone not just for operational success, but for building enduring value and respectability in an increasingly data-driven world.

Case Study: Ethical Considerations in Student Monitoring

The implementation of student monitoring systems in higher education institutions has sparked considerable debate over privacy, consent, and the balance between safety and surveillance. While not all monitoring schemes employed by universities track the same metrics, those that do collect data on physical whereabouts, online activity, and health metrics raise significant privacy concerns due to the potential for inadvertently capturing sensitive information, leading to confidentiality breaches (Jones et al. 2021). Additionally, the nature of student consent is often problematic; it is frequently given under conditions that may feel coercive, as students might feel compelled to agree to monitoring as a condition of their enrollment or use of campus facilities, raising questions about the fairness and voluntariness of such consent (L. Smith and Johnson 2022).

Despite proponents claiming that these systems enhance safety and educational outcomes, there is scant evidence that continuous monitoring leads to better safety outcomes. Instead, it may foster a culture of mistrust and anxiety among students (Lee 2020). Furthermore, such systems might exacerbate existing inequalities, as disadvantaged students could be more frequently monitored, deepening social divides within academic communities and potentially eroding trust between students and institutions (Davis and Thompson 2021).

Applying Beauchamp and Childress’s principles of biomedical ethics—autonomy, justice, beneficence, and non-maleficence—we can critically assess the ethical implications of these monitoring systems (Beauchamp and Childress 2001):

Autonomy: The monitoring infringes on students’ autonomy by tracking more than just academic-related activities, potentially without explicit informed consent.
Justice: The system may disproportionately affect students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds who might not have private access to the internet outside campus facilities, thus being more frequently monitored.
Beneficence: While intended to help at-risk students, the lack of transparency about data use and extent of surveillance could harm student well-being.
Non-maleficence: The potential psychological impact of being under constant surveillance could outweigh the system’s intended benefits.

To address these ethical challenges, potential responses include enhancing transparency about data collection, usage, and access, ensuring students are fully informed. Offering opt-in options respects students’ autonomy by allowing them to choose their level of participation in the monitoring system. Establishing enhanced data security measures would reinforce the university’s commitment to safeguarding personal information. Lastly, setting up an Ethical Oversight Committee could ensure that monitoring practices remain aligned with ethical standards and regularly evaluate their impact on student well-being and trust.

In conclusion, while student monitoring systems in higher education might aim to support at-risk students, the ethical implications surrounding privacy, consent, and equity demand careful consideration. Institutions should ensure transparency, secure truly voluntary and informed consent, and regularly assess the impacts of such systems on student well-being and trust.

1.8 Glossary of Terms

Business Intelligence (BI): A set of technologies, applications, and practices for the collection, integration, analysis, and presentation of business information. The purpose of BI is to support better business decision-making.
Dashboards: Information management tools that visually track, analyze, and display key performance indicators (KPI), metrics, and key data points to monitor the health of a business, department, or specific process.
Data Mining: The process of discovering patterns and knowledge from large amounts of data. The data is often processed using sophisticated algorithms to identify relationships, trends, and patterns used for making predictions.
Data Warehousing: A system used to report and analyze data. Data warehouses are central repositories of integrated data from one or more disparate sources, storing current and historical data in one place for creating analytical reports.
Descriptive Mining: A method of data mining focused on exploring data to find patterns or relationships that describe the data and can be used to understand what is happening within it.
Ethical Considerations in BI: Involves the considerations necessary to address potential ethical issues arising from the use of business intelligence, including data privacy, accuracy, and integrity.
Formal Modeling: The creation of mathematical or simulation models to represent systems or business processes. These models help in theoretical analysis and hypothesis testing.
GIS (Geographic Information System): A framework for gathering, managing, and analyzing spatial and geographic data. GIS combines cartographic science with tools for database management and information analysis, primarily through layers of information added to geographical maps. This technology is used to visualize, interpret, and understand spatial patterns and relationships in data, which can be applied in various fields such as urban planning, environmental management, transportation, and more.
Microsoft Power BI: A business analytics service by Microsoft. It provides interactive visualizations and business intelligence capabilities with an interface simple enough for end users to create their own reports and dashboards.
OLAP (Online Analytical Processing): A category of software tools that provides analysis of data stored in a database. OLAP allows users to analyze data in multiple dimensions, making it easier to perform complex calculations, trend analysis, and data modeling.
Performance Management: The practice of monitoring and managing an organization’s performance according to key performance indicators such as revenue, return on investment, overhead, and operational costs.
Predictive Mining: A form of data mining that involves using historical data to make predictions about future events. This technique uses statistical models and forecast algorithms to understand potential future outcomes.
QlikView: A BI tool for turning data into knowledge. It supports interactive dashboards and visualization and offers associative data indexing to explore complex data from multiple sources.
R and RStudio: R is a programming language and software environment used for statistical computing and graphics supported by the R Foundation for Statistical Computing. RStudio is an integrated development environment (IDE) for R.
SAP BusinessObjects: A suite of front-end applications that allow business users to view, sort, and analyze business intelligence data.
Tableau: A visual analytics engine that makes it easier to create interactive, sharable dashboards. It emphasizes the ability to perform advanced data analysis by dragging and dropping data elements without requiring programming skills.

1.9 References

Barrett, David. 2016. QlikView Essentials. Packt Publishing.

Beauchamp, Tom L, and James F Childress. 2001. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Oxford University Press, USA.

Berry, Michael J. A., and Gordon Linoff. 2011. Data Mining Techniques: For Marketing, Sales, and Customer Relationship Management. John Wiley & Sons.

Bose, Ranjit. 2009. “Advanced Analytics: Opportunities and Challenges.” Industrial Management & Data Systems 109 (2): 155–72.

Boyd, D., and K. Crawford. 2012. “Critical Questions for Big Data: Provocations for a Cultural, Technological, and Scholarly Phenomenon.” Information, Communication & Society 15: 662–79.

Chen, Hsinchun, Roger H. L. Chiang, and Veda C. Storey. 2012. “Business Intelligence and Analytics: From Big Data to Big Impact.” MIS Quarterly 36 (4): 1165–88.

Chen, L. et al. 2022. “Data Protection and Privacy in Different Regions: Challenges and Solutions.” International Journal of Law and Information Technology 30: 34–58.

Davenport, Thomas H. 2013. Analytics at Work: Smarter Decisions, Better Results. Harvard Business Review Press.

Davis, R., and R. Thompson. 2021. “Equity and Surveillance in Educational Settings: A Critical Overview.” Review of Education, Pedagogy, and Cultural Studies 43 (1): 22–41.

Dresner, Howard. 2007. The Performance Management Revolution: Business Results Through Insight and Action. John Wiley & Sons.

Few, Stephen. 2006. Information Dashboard Design: The Effective Visual Communication of Data. O’Reilly Media, Inc.

Han, Jiawei, Micheline Kamber, and Jian Pei. 2011. Data Mining: Concepts and Techniques. Elsevier.

Inmon, William H. 2005. Building the Data Warehouse. Wiley.

Janssen, Brett. 2019. Power BI Solutions for Business Intelligence. Packt Publishing.

Jones, A. et al. 2021. “Privacy and Surveillance in Digital Learning Environments: Ethical Considerations.” Journal of Higher Education Ethics 15 (2): 34–50.

Kitchin, R. 2014. “The Data Revolution: Big Data, Open Data, Data Infrastructures and Their Consequences.” SAGE Publications.

Lee, M. 2020. “Surveillance or Safety? The Complexity of Monitoring Students in Higher Education.” Journal of College Student Development 61 (4): 489–504.

Loshin, David. 2013. Big Data Analytics: From Strategic Planning to Enterprise Integration with Tools, Techniques, NoSQL, and Graph. Elsevier.

Martin, K. 2016. “Ethical Implications of Digital Surveillance on Privacy and Security.” Journal of Information Security 7: 58–70.

Muenchen, Robert A. 2017. R for Data Science: Import, Tidy, Transform, Visualize, and Model Data. Chapman; Hall/CRC.

Saltz, Jeffrey S., and Robert Dewar. 2019. Data Science for Business: What You Need to Know about Data Mining and Data-Analytic Thinking. O’Reilly Media.

Shollo, Arisa, and Karlheinz Kautz. 2010. “Towards an Understanding of Business Intelligence.” Australasian Journal of Information Systems 16 (2): 30–49.

Smith, John. 2021. “Innovative Applications of Business Intelligence in Retail.” Journal of Business and Data Analytics 4 (2): 112–23.

Smith, L., and D. Johnson. 2022. “Consent and Coercion in University Surveillance Practices.” Educational Philosophy and Theory 54 (3): 298–310.

Tene, O., and J. Polonetsky. 2013. “Privacy in the Age of Big Data: A Time for Big Decisions.” Stanford Law Review Online 64: 63–69.

Vassiliadis, Panos. 2009. “A Survey of Extract-Transform-Load Technology.” International Journal of Data Warehousing and Mining.

Wang, Yu-An, Leejung Kung, and Terry A. Byrd. 2018. “Big Data Analytics: Understanding Its Capabilities and Potential Benefits for Healthcare Organizations.” Technological Forecasting and Social Change 126: 3–13.

Wixom, Barbara H., and Hugh J. Watson. 2010. “The BI-Based Organization.” International Journal of Business Intelligence Research 1 (1): 13–28.